Bellendon: Difference between revisions

No edit summary
Line 174: Line 174:
== Critical Commentary  ==
== Critical Commentary  ==


Greg identifies F. G. Fleay as having made the connection between the Admiral's Men's play and the entry in the Stationers' Register on 24 November 1595. Greg refers to the S.R. entry on 17 May 1594 as "probably … a chap-book" and notes the name change of the king from Henry I to Rufus (II.164. Item #42). In the "Lost Plays" section of ''BEPD'' Greg, repeating these observations on the stationers' entries, points out that the two plays with Henry I in the title in the diary are "too late for identification" with ''Bellendon'' (i.e., "The Life and Death of Henry the First" [q.v.] and "The Famous Wars of Henry the First and the Prince of Wales" [q.v.]); he also points out that the "Henry I" ascribed to Shakespeare and Davenport in 1653 is later still (I, Item #14, pp. 966-7).


<br> Gurr identifies the play with the Gosson entry of 17 May 1594 (Apx I.203) and the Blackwell entry of 24 November 1595 (Apx I.204n). Discussing the Admiral's Men's plays generally, he makes two points about ''Bellendon'': (1) he calls the play-character "the clown Belin Dun" (p. 50), and (2) he claims that the play was "never revived" after its disappearance in 1597 from the lists in the diary (p. 36).  
:'''Fleay''' identified ''Bellendon'' with the "prose story" entered by Gosson (above, 17 May 1594) and the Blackwell entry (above, 8 June 1595). He also linked it with the entry in Henslowe's inventory ([http://www.archive.org/stream/abiographicalch02fleagoog#page/n313/mode/2up ''BCED'', 2. 302]).


<br>  
:'''Greg''' accepts Fleay's identifications and comments further that the Gosson (17 May 1594) is "probably … a chap-book" and notes the name change of the king from Henry I to Rufus (II.164. Item #42). In the "Lost Plays" section of&nbsp;''BEPD''&nbsp;Greg, repeating these observations on the stationers' entries, Greg points out that the two plays with Henry I in the title in the diary are "too late for identification" with ''Bellendon'' (i.e., "The Life and Death of Henry the First" [q.v.] and "The Famous Wars of Henry the First and the Prince of Wales" [q.v.]); he also points out that the "Henry I" ascribed to Shakespeare and Davenport in 1653 is later still (I, Item #14, pp. 966-7).
 
:'''Gurr''' identifies ''Bellendon'' with the Gosson entry  (Appx I, p. 203) and the Blackwell entry  (Appx I, p. 204n). Discussing the Admiral's Men's plays generally, he makes two points about ''Bellendon'': (1) he calls the play-character "the clown Belin Dun" (p. 50), and (2) he claims that the play was "never revived" after its disappearance in 1597 from the lists in the diary (p. 36).
<br>
<br>


== For What It's Worth  ==
== For What It's Worth  ==

Revision as of 12:24, 6 February 2012

Anon. (1594)


Historical Records

Henslowe's Diary


F. 9 (Greg I.17)

Under the play list "begininge at newington for "my Lord Admeralle men & my Lorde chamberlen men" for 10 performances, June 3-13:

ye 8 of June 1594 ................ ne ..... R[d] at bellendon ............... xvijs

In Henslowe's play lists beginning 15 June 1594, the date on which W. W. Greg decided that the Admiral's players had returned to the Rose after their 10-day run at Newington with the Chamberlain's players:

ye 15 of June 1594 ................ ..... ..... R[d] at bellendon ............... iijli iiijs
ye 20 of June 1594 ................ ..... ..... R[d] at bellendon ............... xxxs

F. 9v (Greg I.18)

ye 2 of Julye 1594 ............... ..... R[d] at bellendon ............... xxxxijs vjd
ye 6 of Julye 1594 ............... ..... R[d] at bellendon ............... xxxiiijs
ye 11 of Julye 1594 ............... ..... R[d] at bellendon ............... xxvijs
ye 20 of Julye 1594 ............... ..... R[d] at bellendon ............... xxvijs
ye 25 of Julye 1594 ............... ..... R[d] at bellendon ............... xlviijs
ye 31 of Julye 1594 ............... ..... R[d] at bellendon ............... xxvijs
ye 10 of aguste 1594 ............... ..... R[d] at bellendon ............... xxxiijs
ye 19 of aguste 1594 ............... ..... R[d] at bellendon ............... xxjs

F. 10 (Greg I.19)

ye 29 of aguste 1594 ............... ..... R[d] at belendon ............... xxs vjd
ye 11 of september ............... ..... R[d] at bellendon ............... xxiiijs vjd
ye 23 of september ............... ..... R[d] at bellendon ............... xvjs vjd
ye 13 of october 1594 ............... ..... R[d] at bellendon ............... xxjjs

F. 10v (Greg I.20)

ye 2 of november 1594 ............... ..... R[d] at bellendon [t] ............... vijs
ye 15 of novmber 1594 ............... ..... R[d] at bellendon ............... xijs

F. 21v (Greg I.42)

ye 11 of July 1596 ............... ............. R[d] at bellendon [t] ............... xxxvs


On 24 January 1597 Henslowe changed his system of entering receipts to the following three-column format:

F. 26 (Greg I.51)

[March 1597] mr pd ..... 31 .................... tt at belendon ............... 01— 15— 00-04-00

F. 26v (Greg I.52)

[April 1597] ............... 11 .....—[11]—..... tt at belendon ............... 01— 00— 00 - 14 - 00
............... 19 ..... tt at belendon ............... 00— 09— 02 - 00 - 00
............... 28 .....mr pd..... tt at bellendon ............... 0[0]1— 00— 00 - 13 - 00
[May 1597] ............... 20 ..... tt at bellendon ............... 00— 10— 00 - 00 - 00

F. 27 (Greg I.53)

[June 1597] ............... 15 .................... tt at bellendon ............... 00— 13— 00 - 00 - 00
............... 25 .................... tt at bellendon ............... 00— 07— 02 - 00 - 00


Henslowe Papers


Greg, Papers (Appx. I, art. 1, p. 117. l. 75)

Under the heading “The Enventary tacken of all the properties for my Lord Admeralles men, the 10 of Marche 1598”:

Item, ... Belendon stable ...


Theatrical Provenance

Bellendon appears in Henslowe's diary first on 8 June 1594 in the list of plays offered by the Admiral's Men and Chamberlain's Men playing at the playhouse in Newington. It next appears as the initial offering in the playlists beginning 15 June 1594, a date that marks the return of the Admiral's Men to the Rose playhouse (according to W. W. Greg and accepted universally by subsequent scholars). It receives 16 performances in that run. In 1596 it appears for a solo showing on 11 July. Beginning in March 1596/7 it appears into June for a run of 7 performances. There is a note in the margin at the initial March performance of the play, as follows: "begynyng in leant marche 1597." Marginal notes also mark the appropriate change of months in 1597 to April, May, and June. One of the properties for Bellendon, "Belendon stable," is listed in the 1598 inventory transcribed by Edmond Malone. These papers were loaned to Malone by the librarians at Dulwich College, and the originals were subsequently lost.


Probable Genre(s)

History (Harbage uses the title "Rufus I with the Life & Death of Belyn Dun")


Possible Narrative and Dramatic Sources or Analogues


The Stationers' Register contains three entries relevant to the play, Bellendon. Insofar as is known, the texts associated with these entries are lost.


The first entry is dated 17 May 1594 and reads as follows:

Tho. Gosson/ Entred for his copie vnder thand of mr warden Cawood, a booke intituled The famous Cronicle of Henrye the first, with the life and death of Bellin Dun the firste thief that ever was hanged in England." (S.R. I, 2.307b/650 CLIO; Greg, BEPD, I.11) 


 The second is dated 2 August 1594:

John Danter./. Entred alsoe for his Copie vnder th[e h]andes of bothe the wardens an other ballad entituled BELLIN DUNS Confession & (S.R.1, 2.310b/656 CLIO; not in Greg, BEPD)


The third is dated 24 November 1595:

Will[ia]m Blackwell  Entred for his Copie vnder the wardens hand[es] a booke intituled. The true tragicall historie of kinge Rufus the first with the life and deathe of Belyn Dun the first thief that ever was hanged in England (S.R.1, 3.5b/54 CLIO; Greg, BEPD, I.12)


References to the Play

Rollins traces the ballad entered by Danter on 2 August 1594 to a quatrain quoted in John Taylor's Works, sig. L 1 4 and connects it with the two S.R. entries of 17 May 1594 and 24 November 1595 (Item #180, pp. 23-4).


Spraggs cites the Taylor poem, "An Arrant Thief" and notes that "[a]ccording to the legend, the king founded the market town of Dunstable in order to provide refuge for travellers and a base from which Dun’s activities might be controlled" (n.2) The relevant lines from Taylor's poem as follows:

And England still hath bin a fruitfull Land

Of valiant Thieues, that durst true men stand.

One Bellin Dun, a famous thiefe suruiu'd,

From whom the towne of Dunstable's deriv'd.

(Outlawsandhighwaymen.com)


Critical Commentary

Fleay identified Bellendon with the "prose story" entered by Gosson (above, 17 May 1594) and the Blackwell entry (above, 8 June 1595). He also linked it with the entry in Henslowe's inventory (BCED, 2. 302).
Greg accepts Fleay's identifications and comments further that the Gosson (17 May 1594) is "probably … a chap-book" and notes the name change of the king from Henry I to Rufus (II.164. Item #42). In the "Lost Plays" section of BEPD Greg, repeating these observations on the stationers' entries, Greg points out that the two plays with Henry I in the title in the diary are "too late for identification" with Bellendon (i.e., "The Life and Death of Henry the First" [q.v.] and "The Famous Wars of Henry the First and the Prince of Wales" [q.v.]); he also points out that the "Henry I" ascribed to Shakespeare and Davenport in 1653 is later still (I, Item #14, pp. 966-7).
Gurr identifies Bellendon with the Gosson entry (Appx I, p. 203) and the Blackwell entry (Appx I, p. 204n). Discussing the Admiral's Men's plays generally, he makes two points about Bellendon: (1) he calls the play-character "the clown Belin Dun" (p. 50), and (2) he claims that the play was "never revived" after its disappearance in 1597 from the lists in the diary (p. 36).



For What It's Worth

In Henslowe's Diary for 30 October 1594, there is an entry for "bullen" and receipts of xvs (F 10v, Greg I.20). There is no repeat of the entry, and it is possibly yet another performance of Bellendon.


Holinshed, in the 1577 edition, gives Simon Dunelmensis as the authority on the introduction of hanging in the reign of Henry I (Dr. Henry Summerson of The Holinshed Project identifies this man as Symeon of Durham). For the Holinshed text, see Holinshed


The ballad quoted by John Taylor raises a question about the entry in Henslowe's inventory. Is it "Belendon stable", as Malone transcribed it (a phrasing that suggests horse thieving), or could the original have been "Belendons table," which is more evocative of the name of the town, Dunstable?

Sir John Hayward mentions the story in 1613:

In these times were mighty woods about the place where the two high wayes Watling and Ikening doe ioyne together; which woods were a safe couert and retreite for many robbers, who much infested those high wayes. The most famous thiefe among them, was named [marg. Dunne a famous thiefe.] Dunne, a man mischieuous without mercie, equally greedie of blood and of spoile, the first infamie of his name: Hee was in a sort as the most villanously aduentrous and vile; (for in lewd actions, the worst are greatest) Commander ouer the rest, and of him the place was called Dunstable. To represse this annoyance, the King caused the woods to bee cut downe, built there a Borough, to which hee granted Faire & Market, and that the Burgesses should be so free as any other Burgesses within the Realme. Hee erected there also a Palace for himselfe, and also a faire Church or Priorie; whereto he gaue large priuiledges and endowments. By these meanes hee made the place first populous, and consequently both plentifull and safe. (Hayward, 282-3)



Works Cited

Gurr, Andrew. Shakespeare's Opposites: The Admiral's Company 1594-1625. Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 2009.
Hayward, John. The liues of the III. Normans, Kings of England (London: R.B., 1613).
Rollins, Hyder R. An Analytical Index to the Ballad-Entries (1557-1709). Hotboro, PA: Tradition Press, 1967, Item #180, pp. 23-4.
Spraggs, Gillian. Outlaws and Highwaymen: The Cult of the Robber in England from the Middle Ages to the Nineteenth Century. London: Pimlico, 2001. (outlawsandhighwaymen.com)


Site created and maintained by Roslyn L. Knutson, Professor Emerita,  University of Arkansas at Little Rock; updated 29 October 2009. Addition by Matthew Steggle.